Selma's Chicago Pizzeria & Tap Room San Juan

San Juan Capistrano, CA
1 star2 star3 star4 star5 star

Lunch special

Mon thru Fri - Open to 3:00 pm
Selma's Chicago Pizzeria & Tap Room San Juan (San Juan Capistrano) Lunch special

Wings special

Wednesdays - All day.
Selma's Chicago Pizzeria & Tap Room San Juan (San Juan Capistrano) Wings special

Happy hour

Mondays - All day.
Tue thru Fri - 3:00 pm to 6:00 pm
Selma's Chicago Pizzeria & Tap Room San Juan (San Juan Capistrano) Happy hourSelma's Chicago Pizzeria & Tap Room San Juan (San Juan Capistrano) Happy hour

Reviews

Rachel Haley
Rachel Haley Fri May 26 2023
Value 1 star2 star3 star4 star5 star

It was a great experience for me to come back here. The pizza and wings were delicious, while the fried ravioli and stuffed mushrooms made me feel fuller than when I first visited.


Fabian
Fabian Sat May 20 2023
Service 1 star2 star3 star4 star5 star

The worst customer service experience. We were limited to three tables and the server forgot to bring all necessary food items, silverware or pennies, and was completely unresponsive to our requests. The salads were good but not very good, as expected. Everyone enjoyed their pizza; there are plenty of outdoor tables for sunbathed guests with great company around the pool area.


Amaya Wehner
Amaya Wehner Wed Apr 26 2023
Service 1 star2 star3 star4 star5 star

Despite our reservations, we ended up ordering two pizzas instead of the other two. The waitstaff at this place was unnerving and gave us goosebumps! Plus, they had a baby ship option that cost $52 plus change for dinner--and I'm pretty sure it wasn't over even with Dylan as the bartender.


Rachel Haley
Rachel Haley Mon Apr 17 2023
Service 1 star2 star3 star4 star5 star

The thickness and texture of my thin crust cheese pizza were blatantly too soft to cook with pictures. It would be great if your chefs could be more consistent! I think having a margarita made it even better sounds delicious!


Cole Bergnaum
Cole Bergnaum Sun Apr 09 2023
Menu 1 star2 star3 star4 star5 star

Despite their business name being Chicago Pizzeria, they are clearly lacking in authentic deep dish pizza. Their motto, "we'll save you a trip to Chicago!" makes it difficult to believe that this place is truly as good as their reputation suggests. People who claim the pizza itself is excellent simply need to be taught what exactly constitutes essentially delicious food.


Amaya Wehner
Amaya Wehner Thu Mar 30 2023
Service 1 star2 star3 star4 star5 star

I enjoyed the food at this establishment. My husband opted for the "deep dish" and I went for thin crust, but he found his version a bit oily. The service was also satisfactory, although perhaps too expensive. It would have been more reasonable to charge the same price for preparing if you wanted 6 slice small thin- crust pizza for 17$, considering it was an individual pan size.


Kaci Mueller
Kaci Mueller Fri Mar 24 2023
Value 1 star2 star3 star4 star5 star

I have a peculiar obsession with pizza, and Selma's pizza is one of my top choices. Despite not being from Chicago, however, I still enjoy their delicious meals here. As I relocate to San Juan, though, it'll be improbable that I won't pass up on trying pizza there.


Christian
Christian Sat Mar 18 2023
Menu 1 star2 star3 star4 star5 star

The deep dish pizza we ordered was delicious, resembling BJ'S or Uno’s stuffed pizza, rather like their other Chicago-style pizza. I wish there were more tomatoes on top, but it would have been better otherwise. We also had Extreme Spaghetti and meatballs, which were very tasty (although not overly tender). Wouldn't that have affected our experience in the future? Disclaimer:


Lucinda Runolfsdottir
Lucinda Runolfsdottir Wed Feb 15 2023
Menu 1 star2 star3 star4 star5 star

On our afternoon cruise in San Juan Capistrano, we stopped by Selma's and were thrilled to find that their Chicago style pizza was fantastic. We also had boneless medium wings as an appetizer, which wasn't very tasty but still delicious. After eating some sausage and pepperoni on the way home; it was amazing! Considering its size, they should definitely recommend visiting Ladera Ranch and Rancho Santa Margarrala too.


Fabian
Fabian Fri Jan 06 2023
Menu 1 star2 star3 star4 star5 star

My experience was exceptional when I ordered a deep dish sausage pizza and received excellent service and attention to detail from Jaedyn. The beer selection was also good, and the atmosphere was friendly as well.


Last update on Sun Jul 14 2024   -  

Did you find what you were looking for on this page?

Address & Contact Info

Address 31781 Camino Capistrano, San Juan Capistrano, CA, 92675
Phone number (949) 429-3599
Title Yelp Page
Facebook Facebook Page
Instagram selmaspizzeria
Selma's Chicago Pizzeria & Tap Room San Juan location on map

Trending Events in Orange County